Seahawks Browns Trade

Paytonno1son

Hall of Famer
It seems heavily one-sided with the 1st round pick in there. Rarely are 1st round picks traded for Non-QB type players. If it were Baldwin & a 2nd only, I would have voted approved. But I have been challenged by the Committee head to review all trades thoroughly and to sometimes protect owners from themselves.
 

NightHawkTH32

All-Star
As have I and I agree with payton on this one, the first round pick is too much value for a non Superstar player. Gordon is good but he isn't a superstar. Baldwin is a good and young receiver so I would think about approving Baldwin and a 3rd for Gordon. Possible a 2nd but even that may be alot.
 

majesty95

Admin
Staff member
The most comparable trade to this was Percy Harvin to SEA. That was for a 1st, 3rd and 7th. Baldwin isn't worth a 1st, but at 80 OVR he would be better than most 1st rounders, especially one from where SEA would be picking. Just some insight for you guys to use along with what the committee gave you.
 
Top