Madden 16 Top 5 QB Ratings

[mycaddy]

Frankly as a Lions fan I think Stafford should be at least 90 overall... His numbers dropped last year for a few reason Lions ran more. Megatron was hurt a lot (althought Tate did do a great job while he was gone) and after coming off of alomost 5,000 yards 2 years in a row it seems like he dropped but it had more to do with the offense of Caldwell than him. I dont think his stats deserved a hit at all...

 

[georgiafan]

when you compare Winston to the other Qb he is so overrated it's crazy for someone who hasn't took a snap

 

[majesty95]

Frankly as a Lions fan I think Stafford should be at least 90 overall... His numbers dropped last year for a few reason Lions ran more. Megatron was hurt a lot (althought Tate did do a great job while he was gone) and after coming off of alomost 5,000 yards 2 years in a row it seems like he dropped but it had more to do with the offense of Caldwell than him. I dont think his stats deserved a hit at all...

I think you've been drinking today lol. The guy has an 83 career QB rating and 59% comp pct. he's an above avg QB but that's about it. With that being said, 88 range is probably about right.

Cam is inflated bc of his running ability. That probably adds 4-5 points to his OVR at least. His arm a couple more. He's probably a 79 without the speed and arm strength lol

 

[mycaddy]

Although I am bias as a Lions fan I do believe Stafford deserves a 90... He does have a very strong arm. his weak areas are pocket awareness and understanding defensives which I understand are huge and sometimes his arm gets him in trouble because he will try to force passes when he shouldnt but he is a good very good qb...

As for in this game if his arm strength stays very high and accuracy is good I should be fine...

 

[georgiafan]

Here is a list of Qb ratings that we know so far let me know if you want me to tally up another position.

Rogers 99
Brady 97
Brees 95
Big Ben 95
Luck 94
Romo 93
Peyton 92
Rivers 90
Cam 90
Ryan 90

Wilson 89
Eli 87
Tannehill 85
Stafford 84
A. Smith 84
Palmer 83
Bridgewater 82
Winston 81
Kaepernick 81

Carr 79
Bradford 79
Cutler 79
Foles 79
Mariotta 78
RG3 78
G. Smith 76
Cassell 75
Mallet 74
Bottles 74
Manuel 73
Hoyer 73
Cousins 73
McCoy 73
McCown 72
T. Taylor 72
Manziel 71

TBA
Dalton
Flacco

 

[Adaws820]

Right on point I called Wilson at 89

 

[pack1797]

 

[Adaws820]

No I'm wayyyyy up I feel blessed